Smiling family in front of CFCU branch. Text reads, "2022 Member-owners Annual Report. Strength in Numbers. For you and because of you."Smiling family in front of CFCU branch. Text reads, "2022 Member-owners Annual Report. Strength in Numbers. For you and because of you."


Strong for you and because of you.

1 credit union, 152,852 member-owners, 573 staff members, 25 branches, $5.17 Billion in assets: that is Community First. We believe the exceptional growth and success of your financial cooperative has been achieved by continually giving members more value and staying true to the vision of our founders who believed a financial institution owned by its customers would act in the best interests of its customers. Every member-owner of Community First plays a key role in the success and growth of our credit union. Working together we generate more resources to support the financial health of each other and the communities we call home. We remain committed to our cooperative mission, our focus on people over profit, and ‘finding a way’ to help our members live their best lives with the financial services they need and advice they can trust.  

Home office building with glass and brick reflecting sunlight, with flowering plants and fountain in front.



YOUR FINANCIAL COOPERATIVE
Safe & Secure.

We understand the importance of feeling confident that your hard-earned money is being well-managed and protected, especially during these uncertain economic times. Community First has been recognized as one of the top ten credit unions in the country for our financial strength and performance, for the past 15 consecutive years. Our reserves stand at 11.96% which far exceeds the regulatory reserve requirement of 7% to be considered well-capitalized.  Every dollar we make is put back into the cooperative and the communities we serve. Through our sustainable growth and financial strength, we’re able to provide more value to our members to improve your financial well-being.


Gold horizontal bar.


Lighter purple outline of a trophy cup on dark purple background.

Raddon Crystal Performance Award Winner

We are proud to have received the Raddon Crystal Performance Award for the 15th consecutive year. The award recognizes Community First’s financial strength among the Top 10 Credit Unions in the United States.

 

 

 

BOARD CHAIR/PRESIDENT REPORT
From our leadership

Gold horizontal bar.

Our members and communities endured different challenges in 2022. While we continued to experience the ongoing economic and social impacts of the pandemic, there was the addition of rising inflation, historic rate increases and more recently, the repercussions of California and New York bank failures. To us, these challenges only reinforce our deeply held belief that it’s more important than ever to do business with people and companies you know and trust. Your credit union is the place you own.

There are many ways to measure the performance of a financial institution. Industry analysts rely on quantitative signs of strength, safety and growth. Others look at metrics and ratios that measure net income, capital, and market share. While all of these measurements are important, and Community First is a top performer, we think that the most important measurement is how we serve our members, locally, right here in Northeastern WI. 

Community First’s consistent growth and strong financial performance are reflected in the numbers in this report. We were proud to welcome 11,034 new member-owners in 2022. Solid loan, deposit and asset growth, low delinquency and charge-offs, along with one of the lowest expense ratios in the industry, all resulted in an ROA of 1.40 and record net income of more than $70.4 million. We grew our capital 12.9%, making us one of the strongest financial institutions in the U.S. We take our responsibility as the safe keeper of your money seriously and work diligently to protect and maintain our financial strength.  

But those numbers alone don’t show the thousands of lives that have been made better because of the shared value delivered by your financial cooperative. 

Over our 48 years, Community First has also been widely recognized in our communities as an admired and respected company, an achievement we’re especially proud of because it reflects more than just our strong performance. It speaks to our integrity and unwavering commitment to ‘live our name’ to act ethically and operate responsibly, putting the community of our members, as well as the economic vitality and quality of life of the places they call home, ahead of pure profits. In addition to providing $1.9 million in financial support to local non-profits and organizations, in 2022 our team volunteered more than 20,677 hours supporting 143 charitable and civic causes, sharing their time and talents to help make a positive difference. For us, doing good is essential to doing well. We know that being a good citizen is what you expect from us and, just as importantly, it’s something we expect from ourselves. 

While we see headwinds and continued challenges in 2023, there are also many opportunities. Life takes our members in all sorts of directions. We’re proud to be there for you every step of the way with new products and services, enhanced technology and additional branches to serve your evolving needs. We’re excited about and well-positioned for the future.  

Community First is not just a financial institution and you’re not just someone who banks here. The connection between us is much more than money. You are at the heart of everything we do. You are not customers or clients or consumers or patrons. You are member-owners. And that means something – to us and to you. It means you have a say and a voice that carries weight on all of our shoulders, and it means you and we have an opportunity to do so much more together. On behalf of the Board and Staff, we are grateful for your trust and confidence.

Together, we’ll keep finding a way!

 
Kathryn Sieman, Board Chair signature.
Kathryn Sieman, Board Chair

Cathie Tierney, President and CEO signature.
Cathie Tierney, President/CEO



 

 

MEMBERS SERVING MEMBERS

Board of Directors

Gold horizontal bar.
 

As the financial services industry has dramatically evolved over the years, so has the role of the board. Today, your board is entrusted with the direction of Community First and the complexities that come with oversight for a multi-billion dollar organization. Community First Credit Union’s Board of Directors is an extremely committed group of volunteers, dedicated to ensuring the success and stability of the credit union on behalf of the member-owners.

Kathryn Sieman, Board Chair headshot.


Kathryn Sieman
Board Chair
 
SVP/CFO/Treasurer,
CSE Insurance Group

Sara Micheletti, Vice Chair, headshot.

Sara Micheletti
Vice Chair

 Attorney/Shareholder, 
Sitzmann Law Firm, Ltd.

Monica Hilt, Secretary, headshot.

Monica Hilt
Secretary

Chief Operating Officer,
Ascension Wisconsin

Cathie Tierney, Treasurer, headshot.


Cathie Tierney
Treasurer

President/CEO,
Community First Credit Union

Amy Fricke-Weigel headshot.

Amy Fricke-Weigel
President/CEO,
Fricke Printing Services, Inc

 
Daniel Ferris, headshot.

Daniel Ferris
VP, Chief Legal Officer & Corporate Secretary,
SECURA Insurance Companies

 
Jay Fulkerson, headshot.

Jay Fulkerson
Retired, President/CEO,
Health Payment Systems, Inc.

 

Peter Mariahazy, headshot.

Peter Mariahazy
Chief Administration
Officer, Catalysis

Michael Moore, headshot.

Michael Moore
VP Global Engineering,
Oshkosh Corporation

Paul Schwartz, headshot.

Paul Schwartz
Retired, President/CEO,
Health Payment Systems, Inc.

 
Dr. Susan May, headshot.

Dr. Susan May
President Emeritus,
Fox Valley Technical College

 

We’d like to recognize Dr. Susan May as she retires after 16 years of service to the member-owners of Community First where she held roles of Secretary, Vice Chair and Chairman of the Board. We are grateful that she willingly shared her time and talent to help guide and govern our credit union. Her contributions have made a lasting impact.



Where the strength of the cooperative benefits every member.

 
Gold horizontal bar.
 
Bar chart in teal and lighter teal showing asset growth size 3.177 billion in 2018, 3.413 billion in 2019, 4.234 billion in 2020, 4.926 billion in 2021, and 5.158 billion in 2022.

Asset Growth

In Billions

Reserve growth bar chart in teal and lighter teal showing 404.8 million in 2018, 438.4 million in 2019, 474.1 million in 2020, 528.8 million in 2021, and 587.1 million in 2022.

Reserve Growth

In Millions
Membership growth bar chart with in teal and lighter teal stick figures showing 136,340 members in 2018, 139,822 members in 2019, 145.544 members in 2020, 148,970 members in 2021,  and 152,852 members in 2022.

Membership Growth

Statement of Condition

Statement of Condition chart showing Total Assets in 2021 at $4.9 billion, $5.2 billion in 2022. Liabilities in 2021 $4.3 billion, in 2022, $4.5 billion. Total Liabilities and Reserves in 2021 $4.9 billion, in 2022 $5.2 billion.

Statement of Income

Statement of Income Chart showing Gross Income $151 million in 2021, $188 million in 2022. Total Expenses $68 million in 2021, $84 million in 2022. Net Income is $54 million in 2021 and $70 million in 2022.

In 2022, the Audit Committee authorized the accounting firm of CliftonLarsonAllen, LLP to conduct the annual audit and verification of member accounts.

 

2022 Highlights

 
Gold horizontal bar.
 

From service and product improvements to enhancing our communities, Community First continued living out our name and purpose to serve our member-owners and the communities you call home.

Community First Credit Union Platinum in teal and gray and Visa Debit Card in purple.

Contactless Cards Launched

Incorporating tap-to-pay into our design gave members another convenient and secure payment option.
 

Community First Credit Union team members in teal and blue shirts outside.

Making a Difference

At work and in the community, our team has a passion to make a difference. In 2022, CFCU employees volunteered 20,667 hours.
 

Verifast palm scanner identification technology.

Verifast Introduced

Implementing palm identification technology improved the efficiency and security of in-branch transactions.
 

Woman with laptop reviewing appointment scheduling at Community First Credit Union.

Appointment Scheduling

The added convenience of booking appointments online made it easier to schedule time with our team members.

You are the reason what we do matters.

Gold horizontal bar.
 

Ending 2022 at more than $5.1 billion in assets and serving almost 153,000 member-owners, there is no denying what the power of ‘people helping people’ can accomplish. We have grown and prospered, but what matters most is that we’ve remained true to our purpose – working together in the people helping people spirit of the cooperative, making a difference and succeeding – together.

Infographic describing Community First Credit Union's 2022 financials.Infographic describing Community First Credit Union's 2022 financials.

 
Purple translucent image with volunteers.

Making a difference in the communities we call home.

Gold horizontal bar.
 

We believe in the power of community, so much so, that we made it part of our name. Our goal? To improve the lives of our members and the communities they call home. We continue to give across a broad range of interest areas because our members care about a broad range of needs.

Teal outline of Wisconsin with heart over Appleton, Neenah, Fox Cities.

$1.9 Million

In financial support to non-profit and civic organizations throughout NE Wisconsin.
 
Philanthropic award image of star in teal.

 Philanthropic Award

2022 Outstanding Philanthropic Corporation Award for outstanding commitment and leadership roles in philanthropy and community involvement. AFP-NE WI Chapter.
 
Purple translucent image with volunteers.


Recognition isn't the goal. It's a reflection of the work we do for you.

 

Gold horizontal bar.

 


Local. Trusted. Professionals.

Community First Insurance Center and Community First Financial Advisors provide a full range of insurance products, investments and retirement planning services. We’re proud to report that both programs achieved growth milestones in 2022, serving more members and being recognized among peers across the nation.
Community First Financial Advisors logo in blue and teal stating retirement, investments, planning available through CUSO Financial Services, LP.Community First Insurance Center logo.

 

 

 

Members are the reason for our success.

Man, woman, and child with sucker at Community First Credit Union location.


“I want my kids to have money saved up so they have a secured education. I feel like working with Community First was the right first step.”

Luis V., Member-Owner

 
Woman in blue and white flower shirt inside a Community First Credit Union location.


“Community is service – doing service for others. Community First is definitely a service organization.”

Amy S., Member-Owner

 
Man in checked shirt outside CFCU location with trees in background.


“Community First Credit Union really looks out for the interests of my family. We’ll be forever grateful because our projects wouldn’t have been possible without them. We feel blessed.”

Mark M., Member-Owner
 

Gold horizontal bar.

You are the reason for our success. Thanks to your continued faith and trust in our team members, we’re able to provide better rates, fewer fees, and lower loan rates—all while delivering the genuine, personalized service you’ve come to expect.  

 


Community First Credit Union logo in all capital letters, We'll Find A Way! in italics underneath.


Download printable version